Experienced Personal Injury Attorneys

When should you seek a second medical opinion?

On Behalf of | May 16, 2025 | Medical Malpractice

Medical doctors have access to impressive technology. They can collect tissue for a biopsy and send it off to a laboratory that can evaluate the genetic sequence of the tissue. They can order imaging tests that can look at bones, connective tissue and musculature.

There is a vast assortment of different diagnostic tools that medical doctors can use to determine the underlying cause of a patient’s symptoms. They also have access to a variety of different treatment options, ranging from medications and surgery to physical therapy and other specialized forms of care.

Most of the time, patients accept their doctors’ diagnostic conclusions and treatment plans without question. However, sometimes they misplace their trust. In some scenarios, asking for a second opinion can be a smart decision. What scenarios might warrant seeking the opinion of a different medical professional?

When a doctor disagrees with a patient

In some cases, a patient may relate their symptoms to their doctor, only to have the doctor downplay or dismiss some of their assertions. Other times, the patient may request a specific test because of the symptoms that they have experienced, only to have the doctor refuse to order the test. When doctors are dismissive and reach their own conclusion that contradicts what a patient believes without first validating their concerns, seeking a second opinion might be a wise step.

When a doctor rushes to a conclusion

There are dozens of different potential medical explanations for why a patient has a persistent cough. They could have an infection or possibly even lung cancer.

The diagnostic process requires that doctors rule out explanations before jumping to conclusions or that they affirm a diagnosis through appropriate testing. When doctors diagnose a patient after a single appointment without conducting any tests, the patient may have reason to question their decision.

When treatment plans seem outdated or invasive

Many experienced and competent doctors become quite set in their ways. They may rely on certain medications or treatment options when there are more effective, less costly or less invasive options available.

Patients who question a doctor’s treatment plan may want to consider seeing a second physician to evaluate their other options. The recommendations of another physician may carry more weight than a patient’s protests while developing a treatment plan.

Patients who do not receive a second opinion when they question a doctor’s diagnostic procedures or treatment plan may end up experiencing medical malpractice. They may then need an outside health care provider’s insight to hold the doctor accountable. Communicating with another medical professional can help people advocate for themselves and limit the harm caused by negligent care standards at a specific medical facility.

Archives